Wednesday 2 October 2013
Anonymous Surveyor Without A Clue October 1 2013
Surveyor's visit at flat 12 Curran house, October 1, 2013. The anonymous surveyor who looked a lot like Donal Daly, arrived in the afternoon. As he approached the flat, and stood at the front door his phone rang and he answered it as I stood in the doorway supported by my walking stick. The anonymous surveyor conducted a very abrupt conversation on his phone and when he had finished the call to another person, the abrupt anonymous surveyor who did not identify himself or show his badge asked if he could come in and I agreed. Although I have not seen Mr Daly for some years, I'm pretty certain it was him and let him in as a courtesy in his discourteous state.
First he asked me why he was here, and I said I assumed it was as a response to somebody from the disability team who said he was coming this particular Tuesday afternoon. He was looking at his notes and finding it difficult to work out why he was there in the first place. I said as far as I know, it was to survey the bathroom, toilet and kitchen. That there were leaks either from the shower room or from the toilet in particular. He had a quick look at the shower room/bathroom and asked if it was my installation or a council installation, and shared with him that the installation was one installed by the council. The abrupt anonymous surveyor who might be Mr Daly, had a perfunctory look at the shower, then moved on to the toilet, and he asked me if a plumber had seen the toilet and I said a plumber had seen the toilet which apparently leaks. He muttered that he couldn't understand why it hadn't been fixed straight away. I then mentioned pipework in the kitchen, that there was a problem between plastic and copper pipes and continuous blockages over the years. He did poke his head round the door of the kitchen but did not examine anything either in the kitchen or the toilet. The anonymous abrupt surveyor scratched his head.
Having been on the doorstep answering his phone in a very abrupt manner, the anonymous perfunctory and abrupt surveyor made his way out of my flat and said over his shoulder that I might expect a telephone call. And the visit was faster than the telephone call taken on my doorstep or so it seemed to me. The anonymous perfunctory clueless surveyor who spent more time on his telephone than investigating whatever it was he thought he ought to investigate, left me without a clue as to purpose, real identity and next steps beyond a telephone call sometime.
Overall a very disappointing wait and for what? If the anonymous surveyor, who failed to show any form of official identity, had no clear idea of his purpose, was more interested in answering his phone in a very abrupt manner, failing to identify himself and failing to carry out any particular investigation other than a look, I cannot imagine what the purpose of having a surveyor is in settling the issues which have already been raised and appraised and reported.
I'm truly astonished that the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea is employing people who do not have the right information, the right interpersonal skills, the right professional skills to investigate and an appropriate manner when dealing with people with disabilities, obvious to anyone who might see a person with a walking stick as they were answering their phone. More likely, this particular individual is so self absorbed and so self-important, or maybe they are just so important that nobody else matters. This is a catastrophic nightmare which must have been going on for years if I am right in assuming that this is Mr Daly who came to survey something in my flat. And if I'm wrong and it's not Mr Daly, then there is more than one self-absorbed, self-important individual working as a surveyor for the RBKC TMO Department.
Can you please tell me what I might expect as a result of this particular visit?
Sincerely,
Donald Oddy
Wednesday 21 August 2013
A Specialist Plumber Inspects
Update 21 August 2013
1) As per your request, I have forwarded the pictures below to our Customer Services advisor, Shereen Shaw
[reply: Thank you very much for passing on the photographs. Hopefully this will help send the right sort professional person to investigate flat six.]
2) Please note that Stuart Thompson has left the TMO and the new Repairs Manager’s is Briony Edlington; our Customer Services team are currently progressing the leak issues and will update you accordingly, I have been informed by Ms Shaw that a specialist plumber is due to attend this week
[reply: thank you very much for informing me that Stuart Thompson had left the TMO and has been replaced as stated. I found out that Stuart Thompson had left a couple of days ago when I sent him an email and it said that he had left.]
3) Issues regarding your neighbour’s flat No 6 -thank you for bringing this matter to our attention. Our records show that we do not have any authorisation from flat 6 stating that you can advocate on their behalf that is why we will progress these issues further with the resident of flat 6 directly.
[reply: Thank you for clearing up any misunderstandings about my neighbour. I certainly am not an advocate for other people and their problems. However, the problems that my neighbour has are a direct result of repairs or disrepairs carried out in my flat. Any suggestion that I'm an advocate for anyone else, would be predicated by some permissions stated by that person.]
Update from specialist plumber:
No doubt you will get your own update from the specialist plumber who attended twentieth of August 2013 at midday. This is what he said to me I hope it is accurate and informs you about next steps.
1.the specialist plumber checked how previous repairs were carried out in the kitchen. His understanding of how to do repairs is based on doing the job properly and not just patching up and hoping that the problem will go away. The pipes and how they have been repaired over the last few years is sub standard.
2.the specialist plumber checked the toilet and is quite confident it does not leak. He then investigated behind the toilet panels where the mice live, and found that the wall between the bathroom and the toilet is wet and damp at the base.
3.the specialist plumber inspected various parts of the shower room. There are obvious faults in the installation of the wet room floor and the necessity of using a pump to drain the water away. He said clearly that walk-in showers are better served with a drain system which works on gravity and not with a pump. The specialist plumber said that the installation of the wet room generally was sub standard and likely to leak and cause continuous problems in the future. I suppose we could say that he "the specialist plumber" is right, because the wet room has been a continuous problem over the years I have been a tenant, and this has caused weeks of inconvenience to me.
4.all the specialist plumber can do is tell me the truth as it is. He has no axe to grind and nothing to be defensive about.
5.the specialist plumber suggested I now restart using the washing machine, the kitchen sink, the toilet and the shower room as I would do normally to find out if there is continuous water leak problems down below in flat six.
6.I will have to liaise with my neighbour and let her know that the plumber has made it clear that I need to use my facilities as normal. And if there is a problem, my neighbour will no doubt let you know. As a reminder to you, I do not advocate on behalf of flat six, the tenant in flat six, Julia Taylor, is quite capable and able to report problems if they occur in the future.
Summary:
With the change in management and the advice and understanding that the specialist plumber will pass on to you, maybe there can be a solution offered. So I now know from the specialist that the plumbing in my flat is substandard and installations were also substandard with regard to the wet room. Of course, I have known this and reported this to the TMO repairs Department over the last few years. And the obstructive behaviour of the TMO's staff, and assertions about how plumbing works, and how to deal with mice who live at the back of my cupboards is now clear to both you and the TMO repairs Department.
This is a real life situation which requires proper consideration and professionals who can do the job. If a surveyor is going to come and look and make some decisions about the current conditions of my substandard and badly fitted plumbing, I want to know that the surveyor who is coming to see the property is properly qualified and has the right credentials. In particular, I do not want Mr Daly to have anything to do with assessing the current situation, and I do not want to be involved in the decision making process, other than to know the best way forward at this stage. And it is obvious to me, that matters can be put right if you have the right professional people doing a professional job so that the plumbing will work without further problems.
And if you are to send any more people to do work on this flat, which is owned by the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea, and you manage the repairs and all other services, I need to know that the people are qualified. If you want to send people here, I want their identification to be correct and I want them to be named in the repairs service department data base so you can be confident and I can be confident of their ability to do the job.
It is obvious there are old customs and practices going on, and the suggestion with the changing TMO repairs services now going in the house does not fill me with confidence at this time.
Don't forget I am the one at the receiving end of all the nonsense that goes on. The TMO repairs Department no doubt is responsible not only to the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea, it is responsible for putting things right when things are wrong for the clients or tenants or whatever you call us.
With regard to the specialist plumber. I would suggest that you don't shoot the messenger, and make it possible for you to hear what he has to say. Obviously this whole situation is a direct criticism of the TMO repairs Department and how they conduct themselves as individuals and representatives of the TMO. It is likely that people in the TMO will be defensive and obstructive because they have been allowed to get away with it for many years. And now is the time for the TMO repairs Department to listen carefully and to change their attitudes and behaviour, to change their working practices and to get the job done right first time. And because the TMO repairs Department is going to run an in-house service I hope that the necessary changes to get jobs done properly happens sooner rather than later.
From: (T) Complaints
Sent: Monday, August 19, 2013 4:23 PM
To: 'Don Oddy'
Subject: RE: photos of Flat 6 Curran House For Ms Shaw
Dear Mr Oddy,
Thank you for your email of last Friday 16th August and for the two further emails received today.
1) As per your request, I have forwarded the pictures below to our Customer Services advisor, Shereen Shaw
2) Please note that Stuart Thompson has left the TMO and the new Repairs Manager’s is Briony Edlington; our Customer Services team are currently progressing the leak issues and will update you accordingly, I have been informed by Ms Shaw that a specialist plumber is due to attend this week
3) Issues regarding your neighbour’s flat No 6 –thank you for bringing this matter to our attention. Our records show that we do not have any authorisation from flat 6 stating that you can advocate on their behalf that is why we will progress these issues further with the resident of flat 6 directly.
Yours Sincerely
Ewa Sobczak
Complaints Officer
Monday 19 August 2013
Water Damage Flat 6 Curran House
Previous Video Sent about my concerns about repairs
Email To TMO Duty Surveyor
for advice and information on what I need do next
From: donoddy@hotmail.com
Sent: Friday, August 16, 2013 12:37 PM
To: Stuart Thompson
Cc: Ewa Sobczak Sobczak ; Tim Coleridge ; leader@rbkc.gov.uk
Subject: Re: Update - 12 Curran House
Dear Stuart,
Thank you for your email and the updates, which put me in a place of hopeful anticipation of good things to come. I am concerned however, the return of rodents and the return of plumbing issues have manifested in recent weeks. Following a blockage in the pipework a couple of weeks ago, I had to pull out the refrigerator and washing machine to clear up and was confronted by two mice running into the back of the cupboard's due to flooding caused by a blocked pipe. I reported the matter to the TMO and a few days later two plumbers spent several hours unblocking the waste pipe which runs from the kitchen sink and round the back to the main stack.
This morning, a call from the TMO asking me to wait in for a plumber because my neighbour number six below me reported flooding in her flat. I am waiting currently and writing to you at the same time about what is going on. I went down to see my neighbour earlier and her flat has suffered significant water damage which she informs me has been reported over the last few months. I had a look at the conditions in flat number six, the bathroom, the kitchen and toilet is dangerous at the very least for a disabled or able bodied person. There is damp, water dripping off the ceilings and significant mould in the kitchen. I have also been outside and looked at the brickwork between my flat and my downstairs neighbour, andthe wall is very obviously damp, not from rain, the brickwork looks like it is saturated with water. I can also see damp above me on the same wall.
I really don't know what to say next, and I don't know what needs to be done. I will document and photograph my downstairs neighbour's bathroom, toilet and kitchen and forward the photographs on if you would like me to. I am sure given our conversation and the positive responses that this must be an issue of some importance to you considering that these repairs over the last few months have been substandard, or one repair has led on to further damage and destructive interventions by people tasked with putting matters right.
I could do with some guidance with regard to next steps as a matter of urgency. The conditions in the flat below me, currently occupied by a disabled person, no one ought to be left living in those conditions, that is my opinion. Can you please advise what to do next,
Yours sincerely,
Donald Oddy
From: Stuart Thompson
Sent: Wednesday, July 17, 2013 10:49 AM
To: mailto:donoddy@outlook.com
Subject: Update - 12 Curran House
Dear Mr Oddy
May I thank you for your time on the 8th July 2013; I hope you were left in a positive frame of mind in regards to the work which is on going to set up the internal repairs service for the TMO. I found it useful to discuss the larger picture and review parts of the project which I am involved with. Whilst we expect some disruption in September 2013; I strongly believe there will be a long term improvement in one of our most important services that we deliver to our residents.
A couple of actions that we agreed have been referred, in that the Area Surveyor will visit the flat below you to ensure that no water penetration is being experienced, which I do not believe to be the case, and I have also forwarded your details to the team who are involved with the Repairs Direct Engagement Panel, so you should expect some contact in the future in regards to your offer to contribute to the current project.
I would like to thank you for taking the time to make your complaint, now that this case has been concluded I would hope that some lost confidence has started to return. Please do not hesitate to contact us in the future should you have any repair related queries.
Yours sincerely
Stuart Thompson
TMO Repairs Manager
Sunday 18 August 2013
Friday 28 June 2013
Update TMO June 27
Complaints Officer
Thursday 27 June 2013
TMO Repairs June 27
The Carpenter arrives yesterday after 11 o'clock. Promised between eight and nine last week, so the work can be done expeditiously and without too much inconvenience, given my health. Between last week, and today… Last week Willmott Dixon turned up on Friday when I was expecting somebody from the TMO repairs office. Willmott Dixon delivered a hamper, which I had asked not to be delivered, and yet at the time of delivery. I was trying to work out why Willmott Dixon had turned up and not the TMO. The hamper a gesture of goodwill by the contractors Willmott Dixon. I don't believe half of what is said these days, because what is said by different people leads me to different conclusions. And it makes me quite irritated that no one seems to know what the other ones are doing.
The repairs to properties of my landlord are carried out by the TMO repairs Department who contract the work to different companies. Depending on the nature of the complaint or repair and need for timely action is indeed the function of the TMO repairs Department. From March 27 to June 27, from a blocked drain to a shower room problem to rodents getting into my abode, the process, the miscommunications and lack of timeliness has been very frustrating. And still, the TMO repairs Department do not seem to be able to offer anything in terms of truthfulness about what has happened and is happening.
When the handyman came round, actually I should say the contractor, thought to be a carpenter by me, turned out to be helpful and yet programmed to deliver a different solution to the one offered. I spent quite considerable time clearing out areas in the kitchen so that the Carpenter could then fill in and make good holes in cabinets and cover-up the voids behind them. When the Carpenter came, he said, "what I need to do is find out where they are coming in, the mice, and block up the holes which cause them access." I was happy with this because that seems to be the right thing to do. So he went and got his tools, wire wool and some cans of expandable filler.
Meanwhile, with the quick discussion with the contractor about what appeared to be leaks in the toilet, I realised that there was a principle of physics, which had an impact, and to which I was totally ignorant in scientific terms, "Bernoulli's principle applies to the concept of fluid dynamics, and states that an inviscid flow – one without resistance or interference – can only be produced when an increase in the speed of the fluid occurs at the exact same time as a decrease in pressure or a decrease in the potential energy of the fluid. Any imbalance between these two properties results in interference in the substance's fluidity." So I am now very uncertain about previous comments to do with leaks from the soil pipe!
And then the contractor blocked up the holes which previously would have been concrete and brick with wire wool and expandable foam. All very good. If it works, I will be delighted to have less of a rodent problem.
I took some photos, it seemed an appropriate thing to do. Where once there was brick and concrete, and as a layman what looks like asbestos covering the floor, there is now wire wool and expandable foam. Although the building does not seem to be falling down, the option of wire wool and expandable foam instead of brick, concrete and what looks like asbestos, the solution may well be okay?
What I learned so far from yesterday's visit? Since I have been here, the rodents have had access through all the backs of the cupboard's in voids in the wet room, the toilet and kitchen. And that the extent of the holes in the kitchen cupboards was far more of a problem than I ever imagined. What it means for me is that for several years rodents have had access. And by the time I get to see the evidence, and have contacted the TMO about it, the problem has manifestly been bigger and more extensive than is obvious. I do commend the pest control Department for their part in this, putting down bait to kill them off, at the same time the access points and the holes for the rodents have been exposed for quite a few years prior to my living here.
I really am gratified to know the science behind what seemed to be a leak in the toilet, even though there is oxidisation on the copper pipes as can be seen in the photographs. And what suspiciously looks like asbestos in the floor behind the WC does concern me.
The backs of the kitchen cupboards are exposed, the pipework coverings on pipes from the boiler still have quite wide gaps. The toilet? And the bathroom/wet room floor has come off to a degree and the side wood panels/flooring are not glued correctly. Progress. I guess?
What happens next?